This Week's Flagship Article
US Intelligence Says Iran Government Not Near Collapse Despite War Pressure | Inside Stories
- Get link
- X
- Other Apps
Thirteen days of bombing. Thousands of targets struck. Iran's Supreme Leader dead. And Washington's own intelligence agencies have quietly concluded: the regime is not collapsing. That one fact is now the most important thing happening in this war.
What US Intelligence Actually Says
On March 11, Reuters reported what no Pentagon briefing had said out loud: US intelligence agencies have concluded Iran's government is not at risk of collapse. Not from airstrikes alone.
Three sources familiar with the classified findings told Reuters that a large number of intelligence reports provide consistent analysis that the regime "is not in danger" of collapse and "retains control of the Iranian public." The assessment was completed within days of the report. The Office of the Director of National Intelligence and the CIA declined to comment. The White House did not respond.
Israeli officials have privately reached the same conclusion. In closed discussions, senior Israeli figures told Reuters there is no certainty the military campaign will lead to a collapse of the clerical government.
Regime change was one of Trump's stated goals going into Operation Epic Fury. His own intelligence community is now telling him that goal is not achievable through bombing alone.
Why Iran Has Not Fallen
When the strikes killed Supreme Leader Ali Khamenei on day one, some in Washington assumed the regime might unravel. It did not. An Interim Leadership Council was in place within 24 hours. By March 8, the Assembly of Experts had elected Mojtaba Khamenei as the new Supreme Leader. The transition took eight days. The IRGC never stopped operating.
On March 12, Mojtaba Khamenei appeared on Iranian state television declaring the Strait of Hormuz must stay closed and that attacks on Gulf neighbors would continue. Iran's Foreign Minister Abbas Araghchi told NBC News: "We didn't ask for a ceasefire even last time. We are confident we can confront them." When asked whether Iran feared US ground troops, he said: "No. We are waiting for them."
On the covert side, the CIA was reportedly working with Iranian Kurdish groups in Iraq to stir unrest inside western Iran. That effort has stalled. New intelligence assessments cast doubt on whether these groups have the firepower to sustain a fight against Iran's security forces. Kako Aliyar of the Kurdish opposition party Komala told Fox News that Kurdish forces cannot move against the regime because Iran can still hit back with missiles and drones. For a forced collapse, sources told Reuters, the US would likely need a ground offensive inside Iran. Trump has not ruled it out. He has not committed to it either.
Hormuz: The Real Weapon
Iran's actual weapon in this war is a 33-kilometre-wide chokepoint. The Strait of Hormuz carries roughly 20 percent of the world's daily oil supply. Since the war began, commercial traffic through it has fallen to near zero. Three cargo ships were struck near the Strait on the morning of March 11 alone. The IRGC declared any vessel linked to the US, Israel, or their allies a "legitimate target." Saudi Aramco called the disruption "by far the biggest crisis the region's oil and gas industry has faced."
Oil prices spiked above $119 a barrel in the opening days of the war. As of March 11, Brent remains above $100. The IEA authorised an emergency release of 400 million barrels from member reserves. Japan, which imports roughly 70 percent of its oil through Hormuz, began tapping national reserves. Qatar's QatarEnergy suspended LNG production. Saudi Arabia and Kuwait have cut output because storage is filling up with nowhere to send it.
Iran is also laying naval mines in the Strait. Clearing them after any ceasefire will take weeks. France's Emmanuel Macron is coordinating discussions around a post-war naval escort arrangement for commercial ships, though retired French admirals have publicly described sending warships into the Strait right now as "suicidal."
Three cargo ships were struck near the Strait the morning we reported this. Read the full breakdown: Three Ships Hit in One Morning: The Strait of Hormuz Is Already a War Zone →
Nobody Knows How This Ends
Trump told CBS News the war is "very complete, pretty much." He told reporters in Miami it will end "very soon." He told Axios on March 11 there is "practically nothing left to bomb." Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth said the same week the war will not end until "the enemy is totally and decisively defeated." Israeli Defense Minister Israel Katz said the operation will continue "without any time limit." These positions cannot all be true at the same time.
Trump's envoy Steve Witkoff was asked by CNBC how the war might end. His answer was three words: "I don't know."
Iran's conditions for ending the war include recognition of its rights, reparations for the assault, and international guarantees against future strikes. Regional intermediaries have told media outlets Iran will not consider a ceasefire unless Israel is also prohibited from striking Iran going forward. Israel has no intention of agreeing to that. The gap between those positions is where the war currently sits.
On the nuclear question: CSIS analysts say Iran still holds an estimated 400 kilograms of 60 percent enriched uranium, and the exact location of that material remains unknown following the strikes. General Dan Caine, Chairman of the Joint Chiefs, did not mention Iran's nuclear programme at all in his March 10 public briefing. The war's first week cost an estimated $11.3 billion, per a Pentagon briefing to Congress. At least seven US service members have been killed and around 140 wounded as of March 11.
Washington used this same war as leverage to pressure India over its oil purchases. We covered it directly: Who Gave America the Right to Decide Where India Buys Its Oil? →
Editorial View
Thirteen Days In. No Exit Plan. No Definition of Victory.
The intelligence community says the regime is intact. Iran's new Supreme Leader is on state television. Its foreign minister says they are ready for a US ground invasion. Trump's own envoy says he does not know how this ends. That is not a military campaign with a clear objective. That is a war being improvised day by day, with oil markets and global shipping paying the cost.
Iran's approach is patient. It does not need to win militarily. It just needs to make the war expensive enough and chaotic enough that Washington feels political pressure to negotiate. Close the Strait, hit Gulf infrastructure, keep oil above $100, wait. That plan is working. Oil prices are elevated, global allies are restless, and US gasoline prices are at their highest point under either Trump term.
If bombing alone cannot collapse the regime, and a ground invasion is not on the table, what does winning actually look like? Iran's nuclear material location is unknown. Its new Supreme Leader is defiant. Its ceasefire conditions are unacceptable to Washington. At some point, defining what the goal is becomes the only question that matters.
The Bottom Line
Thirteen days. Thousands of strikes. A new Supreme Leader installed in eight days. Oil above $100. The Strait effectively closed. US intelligence saying the regime is going nowhere. Iran's foreign minister saying they are ready for ground troops. And Trump's envoy saying he does not know how this ends. This war started with military objectives and no political exit. That gap has not closed.
Santhosh writes about geopolitics and global affairs. For his work on web development and writing, visit santhoshvishwamitrablog.wordpress.com.
- Get link
- X
- Other Apps
Comments
Post a Comment